The most recommended psychological horror books

Wayward is the sequel to Wanderers, which was my number one favorite read of 2022. These books are incredible for several reasons.

The voice Wendig employs is conversational and impactful, the themes are heavy yet hopeful, and the characters were so real and relatable that I still think of them often, though I finished the book back in January.

Oh, and the mystery at the heart of the plot is so compelling it made this 800+ page doorstopper fly by in no time. This is the first post-apocalyptic story I’ve read that left me feeling ultimately hopeful about humanity’s inherent goodness, and for that, it tops my list.

Natsuki is an outsider to polite Japanese society. She is content with an asexual-by-design marriage and comfortable questioning the norms and expectations of marriage and babies. She also has an alien called Piyyut living in her backpack, which happens to be a talking plush hedgehog.

Wherever you think this bizarre, bonkers novel is going, it goes even further–I read the final pages with my jaw basically detached.

To set the record straight, I do not love this book. I still haven’t come to a decision if I even like it. It isn’t the “best” book on my list, yet it is the most disturbing. And it is a must-read.

A warning, though. It’s a book that you won’t be able to stop and you’ll likely feel very guilty for even reading it. It dives into human behaviors that we don’t want to think about and surely would not intentionally want to take part in. I’ve a question for you: Is there a limit to what you would do to another human being if others were doing it too? How confident are you in your answer? The worse part about this novel is that it is based on a true story.

I love this book because it is about a family of witches, one of my favorite paranormal subjects, originating in old New Orleans, the creepiest, coolest city in America. Second, it is Anne Rice, my favorite author, bar none.

The protagonist, Rowan, is a doctor who learns that her superb medical skills are due in part to the supernatural abilities she has inherited from the Mayfair witches.

As a neuroanatomist, I can imagine what it would have been like if I had powers like telekinesis and clairvoyance and how that could have helped me in my brain mapping research as a PhD student. I also love the fact that the Mayfair witches owe their powers to a sexy male-presenting immortal being, Lasher, who is both lover and fiend.

Joyce Carol Oates is genuinely an extraordinary author, known for her prolific output. While some writers focus on series, Oats dedicates her time to crafting numerous standalone books, each a gem in its own right. 

The plot may appear simple at first glance—a missing sister, and a protagonist who must piece together the clues to find her. However, as the story unfolds, the reader becomes immersed in a web of subtle evidence that gradually weaves together, resulting in a rich and suspenseful novel. Put the book down.

I’m a sucker for found narratives, for stories told in annotations, and for ambiguous endings; there was no way I wasn’t loving this book.

Art Barbara saw some stuff, or thinks he did, when he was a kid. The stuff involved his friend, who’s drifted in and out of his life over the decades. He’s written a memoir, and his friend has found it, and… the blurb says, “she’s making cuts,” but really what she’s doing is adding her own opinion, or at least her own spin.

Both voices are engaging and distinct, both in the prose and in the narration by Graham Halstead and Xe Sands. Tremblay’s novels are all great, but whether it’s because it was my first or his latest, I liked this one the best.

This is another book that kept me guessing all the way through–not only about the whodunnit but also about what kind of book it even is.

I loved Vesta Gul, an older widow who just moved into a rural community, as the unlikely sleuth. You’d think she had enough problems living in the middle of nowhere with no support network other than her dog, but after she finds a mysterious note in the woods, she’s determined to solve the murder mystery on her own, even before she finds a body.

I enjoyed watching her find a destructive new sense of purpose as she stopped at nothing to complete the case.

Lotz's book is an intense character study, painting a portrait of her protagonist in masterful strokes.

Simon Newman is complex – simultaneously thrill-seeking but lazy, ambitious but anxious, traumatized but desperate to hide his weakness.

He has no business searching for bodies in the notoriously dangerous Cwm Pots, and he takes away exactly the wrong lessons from his survival. He certainly has no business on Mount Everest, and knows it. But now he's haunted by the (possibly literal) ghosts of his own bad choices, and he's in too deep now.

This book is a journey in its own right. 

Golding is an excellent stylist and manages to combine the detective story with the fantastical element of Irish myth: the Selkie. Is the young mother truly a seal longing to return to the sea? Who is not fascinated by a creature from another world? I know I am. Like her, I have sometimes felt that I am only a visitor here, yearning for my true home. Maybe we have all known something of that feeling, and that’s why we know that on some level, the Selkie is real. The audiobook narration is superb.

Riley Sager is one of my favorite authors, and this book is my favorite of all his books.

The secluded location? A speeding car. The main character, Charlie, needs to get home from college and shares a ride with a new acquaintance who may or may not be a serial killer. I loved the tension woven into each chapter, the slow unraveling of Charlie’s past, her suspicious fascination with classic movies, and the relentless, unexpected twists compounding in the end.

This is one of those books that has stuck in my mind and will probably be there forever.