The best non-fantasy novels for fantasy readers

Gary Jonas Author Of Modern Sorcery: The First Jonathan Shade Novel
By Gary Jonas

Who am I?

My mother instilled a love of reading in me, and from an early age, I read everything from Agatha Christie to Edgar Rice Burroughs to Louis L’Amour to Marvel Comics. Stories are stories no matter how they’re classified, and genre is primarily a marketing tool to help readers find things they like. When I started writing, I often blended genres because I liked so many things. As I type this, I have 29 novels published with #30 on the way. The novels include science fiction, fantasy, horror, and thriller under my name, westerns as Dan Winchester, and a cozy mystery as Angie Cabot. Go figure.

I wrote...

Modern Sorcery: The First Jonathan Shade Novel

By Gary Jonas

Book cover of Modern Sorcery: The First Jonathan Shade Novel

What is my book about?

Modern Sorcery at its core is about friendship. On the surface, it blends fantasy with mystery. The hero, Jonathan Shade, is a private investigator who handles cases dealing with magic and the supernatural. His protector, Kelly Chan, is a magically engineered assassin devoted to Jonathan because he showed her she could be more than just a killer. Esther, his secretary, is a ghost from the 1920s flapper era bound to her typewriter, and not-so-secretly in love with Jonathan. It’s the first of twelve novels about these characters. They’re loaded with action and humor.

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

The Books I Picked & Why

The Cowboy and the Cossack

By Clair Huffaker

Book cover of The Cowboy and the Cossack

Why this book?

This is one of my all-time favorite novels. A group of Montana cowboys must drive a herd of cattle across Russia in the early 1880s or a village will starve. You’re thinking, dude, this is Lonesome Dove set in Russia. Fair point, but this book came out a decade before the McMurtry novel. And in my humble opinion, it’s a better book. Yes, that’s a bold statement. The scenes are so beautifully written and executed, that you feel like you’re there. Fantasy readers will appreciate the clash of cultures as well as the coming-of-age story that gives the book its heart. I envy those of you who get to meet Levi, Shad, Rostov, and the rest for the first time. This is a book to be treasured and re-read.

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

Doomsday Book

By Connie Willis

Book cover of Doomsday Book

Why this book?

Granted, it’s not a big stretch to go from fantasy to science fiction, and this amazing novel won both the Hugo Award and the Nebula Award. Connie Willis is one of the best writers in science fiction, and this is her masterpiece. It’s a time-travel story about a woman named Kivren who ends up stranded in the 14th century during the Black Death. Meanwhile, in the future, an influenza epidemic breaks out, and they’re afraid it may have come from sending Kivren back in time. I know, a charming selection during the time of Covid. But trust me, it’s an amazing novel, and deserves every award bestowed upon it. Fantasy readers will really appreciate the setting and characters. Don’t miss this one.

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

The Killer Angels: The Classic Novel of the Civil War

By Michael Shaara

Book cover of The Killer Angels: The Classic Novel of the Civil War

Why this book?

This amazing Civil War novel blew me away. The viewpoints shift between the men and leaders on both the Union and Confederate sides. Friends facing friends across a battlefield. Moral dilemmas abound. What does it feel like to be in the heat of battle? This novel personalized the Battle of Gettysburg by diving into the hopes and dreams of the men who fought and died there. I can see why it won the Pulitzer Prize. Fantasy readers in particular will appreciate the battle scenes, but also the tactics and, as I seem to mention a lot in these notes, the depth of character. That’s something that all five of my selections share. Fiction is about folks.

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

L.A. Requiem: An Elvis Cole and Joe Pike Novel

By Robert Crais

Book cover of L.A. Requiem: An Elvis Cole and Joe Pike Novel

Why this book?

This novel was a revelation to me. First, I’ll note that it’s a book in the Elvis Cole series, and the earlier novels were told in the first person (with a couple of exceptions for prologues). This book changed everything by going full-on multiple viewpoints, and in so doing, deepened the characters in amazing ways. It’s not necessary to read the earlier books to enjoy this one, but I predict you’ll get addicted to Crais and read all of them anyway. This novel will appeal to fantasy readers by reminding them how great books can affect us by awakening our humanity and letting us know we’re not alone in the world.

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

The Brotherhood of the Rose

By David Morrell

Book cover of The Brotherhood of the Rose

Why this book?

On one level, this novel is about Chris and Saul, two orphans raised by Eliot, a CIA operative, to become world-class assassins. After an international incident, Eliot decides Chris and Saul must be eliminated. Solid and engaging on that level, of course. But on a deeper level, it’s about two young men who trust their “father,” the one person who ever cared about them, only to feel the sting of his betrayal rock them to their core. The emotion makes the action matter. Everything is personal. The accurate tradecraft, killer action, and depth of character all combine to make this one of my favorite books. Fantasy readers will appreciate the secret society aspect of the assassins as well as the amazing action set-pieces.

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

Closely Related Book Lists

The best books on Civil War soldiers and home life experiences

Steve Magnusen Author Of To My Best Girl: Courage, Honor, and Love in the Civil War: The Inspiring Life Stories of Rufus Dawes and Mary Gates Steve Magnusen

The best books with plots so mind-bending they are scary

B.A. Bellec Author Of Pulse: Book One B.A. Bellec

The best novels about virtual reality games

Ramsey Isler Author Of Ghosts of ARCADIA Ramsey Isler

The best novels on what it means to be LGBTQ+

Akiva Hersh Author Of The Magus and The Fool Akiva Hersh

Distantly Related Book Lists

The best dystopian books to devour your soul

Halo Scot Author Of Edge of the Breach Halo Scot

The best historical novels that I love to recommend

Andrew Hudgins Author Of After the Lost War: A Narrative Andrew Hudgins

The best books about dark futures that aren’t without hope

Alexandra Oliva Author Of The Last One Alexandra Oliva

The best books on understanding the future in a climate changed world

Andrew J. Hoffman Author Of How Culture Shapes the Climate Change Debate Andrew J. Hoffman