The best books that make you solve the mystery

I have always loved detective noirs, but the genre is becoming increasingly rare, and the new stories that are released are usually not nearly as unique as they once were. This is why reading this book for the first time felt so refreshing. It’s a perfect distillation of everything that makes classic noirs great, with fresh stories, ideas, and breathtaking artwork.

It tells serious stories without taking itself too seriously, all of its mysteries have great payoffs, and the characters are incredible, especially the titular cat, John Blacksad, and my personal favorite, Weekly the Fox. I loved the first story and have since made it my mission to collect the rest of the series!

Who doesn’t love a high-concept twist? This type of story is so intricately plotted that every single clue within the book offers a massive payoff, down to the last detail. There is nothing I love more than a book that gives me all the clues I need to figure out its mystery but still manages to shock me in the end.

From the detectives that the story follows to the claustrophobic island setting, it made me think of the classic “whodunnit” stories. This time, the mystery is far more complex, and the answer is far more haunting.

This might just be my favorite graphic novel of all time, as well as one of my favorite crime stories, period. It combines two of my favorite genres, crime epics and murder mysteries, into one epic story with one amazing hook after another.

The theme of holiday-themed killing is fun, the Calander Man gives his best Hannibal Lecter impression, and the scope of the Mob’s reach in Gotham City is explored to perfection. Add to that the best Two-Face story of all time, alongside all of the Dark Knight’s other infamous rogues, and you get one of the best detective stories of all time.

It also helps that the late Tim Sale’s artwork remains second to none in the noir genre.

The thing I love the most about this book is its incredible pacing. While it's not nearly as complex as the mystery in my previous recommendation, and the final twist is not as shocking as Shutter Island, it is a book that you pick up on a whim and get hooked so fast that you want to read the entire story in one sitting.

It wastes no time setting up its mysteries, and its dual narrative keeps the reader coming back. To me, it reads like a detective story crossed with a “beach read,” a quick and effective story that has everything a mystery fan could want.

For my final choice, I wanted to go with a childhood favorite: The Bailey School Kids series. While I will admit it has been a minute since I read the books, growing up in school, it quickly became one of my favorite series because of the fun mysteries that it included.

Sometimes, the stories would even scare me, becoming one of my first introductions to “horror” elements within a book. Eventually, I started learning the patterns of the books (as in how the truth of the “monster” was discovered), which was probably one of the first times I learned how tropes are used within stories.

I would highly recommend this series for kids, and writing about it has made me want to reread some of the books myself!