The best middle grade novels featuring a character in a unique or unexpected living situation

Susan Lubner Author Of Lizzy and the Good Luck Girl
By Susan Lubner

Who am I?

As a writer my storylines almost always develop out of the characters and settings I first create. As a reader, I enjoy a book as much (sometimes more!) for the characters and setting in it as I do for the plot itself. My favorite reads have always featured a quirky or bigger-than-life character and a setting that in some instances may seem ordinary but the circumstances of how the character ended up there are far from that. I love the middle-grade novels on my list because the main characters are brave and resourceful and each has an unusual and intriguing path that has led them to where their story takes place.

I wrote...

Lizzy and the Good Luck Girl

By Susan Lubner

Book cover of Lizzy and the Good Luck Girl

What is my book about?

Lizzy Sherman has brought home strays before. Plenty of cats and a one-eyed poodle. But never a human. And not without her parents knowing. Living in a small town in Maine, twelve-year-old Lizzy copes with the pain of loss. When she and her best friend Joss meet a troubled runaway, Lizzy discovers there is something unique about this girl and hides her inside her home, convinced that she is good luck and can protect Lizzy and her family from another tragedy. But what she offers Lizzy turns out to be far greater than luck. With a balance of humor and heart, Lizzy and the Good Luck Girl is a story about loss, love, family, friendship, and at its core, the awesome power of hope.

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

The Books I Picked & Why

A Year Down Yonder

By Richard Peck

Book cover of A Year Down Yonder

Why this book?

Two words. Grandma Dowdel. She is one of the many reasons I love this book. Fifteen-year-old Mary Alice is forced to leave her parents and her home during a difficult time in 1937. A city girl, it’s no easy feat moving from the big city of Chicago to a small town and in with her larger-than-life grandmother who will have you laughing out loud at her very un-granny-like antics. Peck’s punchy, smart, and often hilarious prose, parallels nicely with undertones of a more serious and difficult period of time for many families.  Mary Alice is easy to root for as she finds her footing in a year filled with many new adjustments in a place very different from home.  

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

Beyond the Bright Sea

By Lauren Wolk

Book cover of Beyond the Bright Sea

Why this book?

“When I was a baby, someone tucked me into an old boat and pushed me out to sea.” From the opening lines of this story there is a sense of mystery…an unknown history, unknown even to the main character, Crow, that pulled me in. On a sparsely populated island off the coast of Massachusetts, Crow lives happily with Osh, the man that rescued her from that tiny old boat. But Crow wants answers to questions that tug at her heart. Where does she come from? Why was she put in that boat? The wonderful sense of place beautifully depicted by Wolk, adds a layer of wonder and awe to this page-turner, a story about the true meaning of family. 

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

Louisiana's Way Home

By Kate DiCamillo

Book cover of Louisiana's Way Home

Why this book?

I love characters that make me feel like I’m in the room with them and both Louisiana and her Granny check that box. Quirky personalities abound in this sweet but often sad story about a girl who hits the road with her eccentric caretaker grandmother in the middle of a starry night. Granny insists that the time has come to leave Florida and confront the curse that hangs over their heads. That means leaving everything familiar and dear to Louisiana far behind: Her friends, her cat, her home. The two end up in a small town in Georgia and as Louisiana’s grandmother’s world gets smaller, Louisiana is left to her own devices in a world that seems too big to handle. 

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

Three Times Lucky

By Sheila Turnage

Book cover of Three Times Lucky

Why this book?

Sheila Turnage’s brilliant, snappy writing makes this gem of a mystery one of my all-time favorites. There’s a lot going on in Tupelo Landing where Mo LoBeau washed ashore as a baby after a hurricane. Now being raised by the Colonial and Lana who run the best (and only) Café in town, Mo and her BFF Dale try to solve a murder in which her loved ones may be implicated. Loads of funny and fun in this series. Sidenote: I was elated when a School Library Journal reviewer said this about my novel Lizzy and the Good Luck Girl “. . .delightful details create a similar air to recent quirky classics such as Sheila Turnage’s Three Times Lucky.…”.  Swoon!!!!

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

Sweep: The Story of a Girl and Her Monster

By Jonathan Auxier

Book cover of Sweep: The Story of a Girl and Her Monster

Why this book?

Orphaned Nan is living the scary and treacherous life as a young chimney sweeper. After getting stuck in a chimney and almost killed by fire, she is saved by a mysterious “monster” made out of soot and ash…a Golem. This is the beginning of a beautiful, special friendship. Living in an attic together, Nan and the Golem look out for each other weaving a contrast of love, courage, and kindness into a story set against a brutally harsh backdrop of hopelessness in Victorian London. Jonathan Auxier’s writing is so brilliant and descriptive I could feel the freezing cold of the winter when I read this book! And the contrast of who is really the “monster” in this story will not be lost on the reader. 

When you buy a book we may earn a small commission.

Closely Related Book Lists

The best books to bring American history alive for middle graders

Frances M. Wood Author Of Daughter of Madrugada Frances M. Wood

The best books on the amazing world of trees

Artur Cisar-Erlach Author Of The Flavor of Wood: In Search of the Wild Taste of Trees from Smoke and SAP to Root and Bark Artur Cisar-Erlach

The best historical fiction for young readers featuring journeys

Glen Huser Author Of Firebird Glen Huser

The best books that put a new twist on the Odyssey

Emily Hauser Author Of For the Most Beautiful Emily Hauser

Distantly Related Book Lists

The best books about emotions and suspense

Debra Chapoton Author Of A Fault of Graves: YA High School Thriller Debra Chapoton

The best books about hospitality and the art of dealing with strangers

Will Buckingham Author Of Hello, Stranger: How We Find Connection in a Disconnected World Will Buckingham

The best books on asylum-seeking and displaced children and war

Nicki Cornwell Author Of Christophe's Story Nicki Cornwell

The best books to know the sea

James G. Stavridis Author Of The Sailor's Bookshelf: Fifty Books to Know the Sea James G. Stavridis