The best books with plots Mulder and Scully should have investigated

Why am I passionate about this?

As horror writer, I’m often asked what scares me most, and almost every fear I have is, at its core, about the Unknown. Not just what we don’t know but the things we cannot know. In all my books, I’ve tried to lean into that personal fear as much as possible, and with Heavy Oceans, I was inspired by the cases Mulder and Scully investigated back when the idea of a government lying to and spying on its own citizens seemed almost quaint by comparison to the moments we’re living. And, as the show’s title credit often said, in glowing words that blazed over a darkened sky…"The Truth is Out There."


I wrote...

Heavy Oceans

By Tyler Jones,

Book cover of Heavy Oceans

What is my book about?

It is a story of deep-sea terror and cosmic horror. Struggling with the pressures of being a new father and the weight of regrets, Jamie Fletcher travels to Hawaii in hopes of connecting with his estranged brother, Eric.

After a shocking act of violence, the brothers end up on a fishing boat—along with the captain and his son—in the middle of the ocean, where they encounter an uncanny and terrifying phenomenon that will signal a shift in the evolution of the world.

Shepherd is reader supported. When you buy books, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The books I picked & why

Book cover of Bent Heavens

Tyler Jones Why did I love this book?

Most readers know this feeling well: when a book you love doesn’t seem to get the attention you feel it deserves. That’s exactly how I view Daniel Kraus’ excellent and suspenseful novel, Bent Heavens. Maybe because it was marketed as YA (whatever that means these days), or maybe because he’s so prolific that it can be hard to keep up with all his work.

Whatever the reason, this book features conspiracy theories, a missing father, government secrets, and exactly the kind of fog-shrouded abandoned places Mulder and Scully tend to explore during their investigations. Yeah, it’s creepy. Yeah, it’s mysterious. But more than that, it’s got characters you care about.

By Daniel Kraus,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked Bent Heavens as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it. This book is for kids age 14, 15, 16, and 17.

What is this book about?

Liv Fleming is done with childhood fantasies. Done pretending she believes her missing father's absurd theories about alien abduction. Done going through the motions of checking the traps he set just for her friend Doug's sake. But on the very day she chooses to destroy the traps, she discovers in one of them a creature so inhuman it can only be one thing. In that moment, she's faced with a painful realisation: Her dad was telling the truth. And no one believed him.

Now she and Doug have a choice to make. They can turn the alien over to the…


Book cover of The Loop

Tyler Jones Why did I love this book?

Some writers make me feel like they’ve seen a glimpse of the future or at least a version of the future. I’m not talking one hundred years ahead; more like a year or two.

This book kicks off with a brutal, bloody scene in a classroom that lets us know something’s not quite right in the (fictional) eastern Oregon town of Turner Falls. Interspersed with the rantings of a conspiratorial radio DJ (think Coast to Coast), we follow a group of high school students contending with something way over their heads.

I love this book not just for the plot and characters but for the prose. Johnson brings a ruthless energy and generous heart to his sentences, and it’s exactly the kind of thing that turns my dials. Plus, I have a feeling if Mulder and Scully had been called in at some point during the story, things could have taken a different turn.

By Jeremy Robert Johnson,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked The Loop as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.


Book cover of Black Mouth

Tyler Jones Why did I love this book?

This book damn near ticked every single box I have when it comes to what I love in a novel. 

A complex and conflicted addict as the main character? Check. Regrets? Check. Deep childhood friendships? Check. An evil magician and a creepy carnival? Check and check.

Black Mouth is dark and intense, and even though it plunges straight into the supernatural, it’s very much grounded in the real world. A world full of pain, heartache, loss, and broken people. 

It also features a character with a disability, and he’s drawn with such love and tenderness that I can’t help but think more novels would benefit from disability representation. The character of Dennis is often seen most clearly in the way others interact with him, revealing much about the kindness or cruelty of the other characters. 

A special book that I didn’t so much read as live inside. 

By Ronald Malfi,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked Black Mouth as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

A group of friends return to their hometown to confront a nightmare they first stumbled on as teenagers in this mesmerising odyssey of terror.

An atmospheric, haunting page-turner from the bestselling author of Come with Me

For nearly two decades, Jamie Warren has been running from darkness. He's haunted by a traumatic childhood and the guilt at having disappeared from his disabled brother's life. But then a series of unusual events reunites him with his estranged brother and their childhood friends, and none of them can deny the sense of fate that has seemingly drawn them back together.

Nor can…


Book cover of No One is Safe!

Tyler Jones Why did I love this book?

Is it cheating to pick a short story collection? Nah. Of course not!

Fracassi is one of my favorite writers. And if you want to know why, just check out his incredible novel Boys in the Valley. But a novel (usually) is a single story, and all the ideas therein serve that story. What a joy it is to see a writer unleash his full power, his idea machine, in a collection of short stories.

You get a little boy’s birthday wish that backfires in a horrifying way. A story written from the perspective of a haunted house. Yes, you read that right! The world’s most dangerous beach, along with eleven other stories that are pulpy, literary, chilling, and terrifying. 

I love that Fracassi completely leans into the pulpy nature of these stories, giving us all the shocks and scares that we used to get from the “monster of the week” X-Files episodes. Plus, it’s a whole lot of fun.

By Philip Fracassi,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked No One is Safe! as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

No One Is Safe! presents fourteen stories of macabre, pulpy terror; a book filled with futuristic noir mysteries, science fiction thrillers, alien invasions, and old-school horror tales that will keep you up late into the night. Inside these covers, you’ll discover haunted dream journals and evil houses, birthday wishes gone wrong, a neighborhood cat that cures any disease, a flesh-eating beach, and mysterious skeletons on a hidden moon base. You’ll meet wise-cracking detectives, suburban vampires, murdered movie stars, and monsters of the deep. And remember—don’t get too attached to the characters you’ll meet on these pages because there’s no holding…


Book cover of Guests

Tyler Jones Why did I love this book?

Whether it’s the short story, the novella, or the novel, Burke never fails to go for the throat in wonderfully unexpected ways. This book falls into that niche sub-genre of horror often referred to as “Arctic horror,” although that often just means cold, with lots of snow. 

The staff at a seaside hotel take in a group from a nearby retirement community just as a massive snowstorm strands them all in a hotel that feels like an East Coast version of the Overlook. A combination of John Carpenter’s The Thing and The Shining, Burke finds the terror in small moments that string together into something much larger and horrifying than I anticipated.

I read this book at night just as snowflakes started falling outside the office window. One of those stories (like several of Burke’s themed collections that might be best read at a certain time of year, in certain weather. But, even if you choose to read this book while the sun is shining, I have no doubt you’ll feel a chill creep over your scalp as you uncover the secrets Burke has buried in these snow drifts.

By Kealan Patrick Burke,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked Guests as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.


You might also like...

Death on a Shetland Longship: The Shetland Sailing Mysteries

By Marsali Taylor,

Book cover of Death on a Shetland Longship: The Shetland Sailing Mysteries

Marsali Taylor Author Of Death on a Shetland Longship: The Shetland Sailing Mysteries

New book alert!

Why am I passionate about this?

Author Sailor Women’s historian Cat-lover Temporarily limping But determinedly recovering

Marsali's 3 favorite reads in 2023

What is my book about?

Liveaboard sailor Cass Lynch thinks her big break has finally arrived when she blags her way into skippering a Viking longship for a Hollywood film. However, this means returning to the Shetland Islands, the place she fled as a teenager. When a corpse unexpectedly appears onboard the longship, she can run from the past no longer: Cass and her family come under intense scrutiny from the disturbingly shrewd Detective Inspector Gavin Macrae.

Even if Cass’s local knowledge and sailing wisdom help to clear the Lynch family of suspicion, they may not be enough to stay ahead of the murderer’s game... and avoid becoming the next victim.

Death on a Shetland Longship: The Shetland Sailing Mysteries

By Marsali Taylor,

What is this book about?

When she wangles the job of skippering a Viking longship for a film, Cass Lynch thinks her big break has finally arrived - even though it means returning home to the Shetland Islands, which she ran away from as a teenager. Then the `accidents' begin - and when a dead woman turns up on the boat's deck, Cass realises that she, her family and her past are under suspicion from the disturbingly shrewd Detective Inspector Macrae. Cass must call on all her local knowledge, the wisdom she didn't realise she'd gained from sailing and her glamorous, French opera singer mother…


5 book lists we think you will like!

Interested in brothers, romantic love, and family?

10,000+ authors have recommended their favorite books and what they love about them. Browse their picks for the best books about brothers, romantic love, and family.

Brothers Explore 107 books about brothers
Romantic Love Explore 836 books about romantic love
Family Explore 3,682 books about family