The best feel good mystery books

Who am I?

As a former school psychologist and author of over 45 books, I love reading about characters that are likable, plots that are believable, and settings that I want to visit. My years as a psychologist make it easy to spot poorly written characters that don’t ring true. It is also my years as a psychologist that makes me enjoy a light, humorous read with a guaranteed happy ending.


I wrote...

Murder of a Smart Cookie

By Denise Swanson,

Book cover of Murder of a Smart Cookie

What is my book about?

Yard sales bring out the worst in people. Nobody knows this better than Scumble River school psychologist Skye Denison, organizer of the First Annual Route 66 Yard Sale. Neighborly folk gets downright nasty fighting over plastic knickknacks. But the worst is yet to come... Skye's former summer-job boss, Cookie Caldwell, has just been found murdered - and the sheriff suspects Skye.

The books I picked & why

Shepherd is reader supported. We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through links on our website. This is how we fund this project for readers and authors (learn more).

Death on Demand (Death on Demand Mysteries, No. 1)

By Carolyn G. Hart,

Book cover of Death on Demand (Death on Demand Mysteries, No. 1)

Why this book?

Carolyn Hart is the master of cozy feel-good mysteries. Her writing pulls you into the story. I love how she uses both big names from the mystery world and rising stars in her sleuth’s bookstore. The two main characters, Annie and Max, are an endearing pair of sleuths.


The Cupcake Caper

By Kelle Z. Riley,

Book cover of The Cupcake Caper

Why this book?

This first book in Kelle Riley’s new series has it all—a plot full of twists and turns, a super-smart sleuth, and just a smidge of romance. I love that the sleuth doesn't act impulsively and instead observes and deduces. In addition, there are yummy recipes, a cranky rescue cat, and several quirky secondary characters. I especially like the couple who own a dog bakery and their trained dog that discourages the goose population.


It Takes a Witch: A Wishcraft Mystery

By Heather Blake,

Book cover of It Takes a Witch: A Wishcraft Mystery

Why this book?

Heather Blake’s first Wishcraft mystery is a captivating story that delightfully blends crime, magic, romance, and self-discovery. The suspense remains high throughout the book and is not an easy mystery to solve. The characters and plot are spellbinding and full of charm, enchantment, and humor. I especially love the animals who speak and help provide the clues.


Murder at the Lakeside Library: A Lakeside Library Mystery

By Holly Danvers,

Book cover of Murder at the Lakeside Library: A Lakeside Library Mystery

Why this book?

Holly Danver’s first book in the Lakeside Library series is fast-paced and an easy read that skillfully evokes both the charm and the quirks of a small town. The setting is fun and the characters are likable. It has delightful touches and twists with a nimble plot that will keep you turning the pages until the very end. It provides a fictional vacation at a rustic Wisconsin cabin that includes a private lending library


Killer Transaction

By Catherine Bruns,

Book cover of Killer Transaction

Why this book?

Catherine Bruns’ first book in her new series features a refreshingly new kind of sleuth. Cindy York is an ordinary woman in her 40s with a supportive husband, twin sons, and a typical teenage daughter. There are several wonderful laugh-aloud moments. The violence is off-page, the plot is well done with the reason for murder revealed at the right time. I loved the animals in the story.


5 book lists we think you will like!

Interested in murders, real estate, and criminal investigations?

5,888 authors have recommended their favorite books and what they love about them. Browse their picks for the best books about murders, real estate, and criminal investigations.

Murders Explore 338 books about murders
Real Estate Explore 16 books about real estate
Criminal Investigations Explore 184 books about criminal investigations

And, 3 books we think you will enjoy!

We think you will like Tombland, The Blooding, and Medicus if you like this list.