The best books for the people a little too obsessed with history (and why we can’t recreate the past)

I read this book while working on my own because Horwitz is a master of weaving a story with many characters about a complicated piece of the past. He provides ample detail about the lengths to which reenactors will go for their performances—and some of the methods are outright gross.

But I love that even when Horwitz is grappling with ways that modern interpretations can obscure the actual past, he never resorts to mockery when talking about his subjects. He might disagree with their perspective about the Civil War, but he listens and reports what they tell him. I recommend this for anyone trying to understand how the Civil War still plays such a prominent role in our world nearly two centuries later. 

If you want to learn about pre-industrial life in Europe, there is no better book than this. Langlands travels across multiple countries, learning how to spin wool, herd sheep, and thatch roofs—skills that were once necessary for daily life but have vanished in an age of mass production.

I love the care with which Langlands undertakes these skills and the way he conveys his respect for the masters who keep these traditional crafts alive. As a kid, I dreamed of visiting the past because I wanted to see what the tangible, daily world looked and felt like. Through Langlands’ book, it felt like I got to visit that world. 

The first Jane Austen novel I read was Sense and Sensibility, and the combination of humor, manners, and romance hooked me. But I’ve never been tempted to participate in a costume ball—at least not till reading this book. Scheinman not only offers a detailed biography of Austen herself, he also explores the world of her superfans, the ones trying to recreate that era of manners and ball gowns.

As he states in the opening, Austen writes about different forms of inheritance, and in this book, Scheinman has given readers a look at his own inheritance as the son of an Austen scholar. If you’ve ever wondered what living in Austen’s world might be like, this is the book for you. 

I’m probably biased on two fronts for this book: one, because I got to speak with the author, and two, because I’m obsessed with proteomics, the study of proteins that can help uncover what foods and drinks were consumed in the past. But if you love learning about the science of archaeology and you’re at all interested in beer and wine brewing, this is the best possible book to read.

McGovern takes you through the history of fermented beverages based on what we’ve found in the archaeological record and then works with expert brewers to recreate those past brews. It’s fascinating work, and I’d love to taste one of the concoctions they came up with. 

This is the only fiction on a list otherwise full of nonfiction, but it more than deserves a place on this list. There are so many things to love about this book—its audacious opening line, the lush writing, the twisted relationships—but what I think history lovers might appreciate most is how deeply entwined the characters get with the history of Antiquities.

After all, the main group of characters in this dark academia only come together because they’re all studying Greek and Latin. In fact, the plot hinges on their obsession with Antiquity—but I won’t get too much more into that. I just recommend picking the book up and going along for the ride.