The best historical romance novels that are off the beaten path

Minerva Spencer Author Of The Footman
By Minerva Spencer

Who am I?

I adore romance in all its forms. I’ll read Viking romance, contemporary rom-coms, alien adventure, and fantastical, magical shifter tales to romances that take place in prison or an equipment rental store. But my first love will always be Regency romance, which is probably why I’ve also chosen to write it. The stories that are always closest to my heart, no matter the subgenre, are the ones that succeed in breaking the mold. The five books on this list are only the beginning of the wonderful, unusual historical romances that are waiting for intrepid readers. Happy reading!

I wrote...

The Footman

By Minerva Spencer,

Book cover of The Footman

What is my book about?

The Footman is a Regency Era romance novel that turns traditional tropes on its head. For once, the footman hero in the novel really is a footman, and not a nobleman in disguise…

Publishers Weekly compared The Footman to The Count Of Monte Cristo and awarded The Footman a coveted starred review, calling it “riveting” and concluding that, “Lovers of historical romance will be hooked on this twisty story of revenge, redemption, and reversal of fortunes.”

The books I picked & why

Shepherd is reader supported. We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through links on our website. This is how we fund this project for readers and authors (learn more).

To Have and To Hold

By Patricia Gaffney,

Book cover of To Have and To Hold

Why this book?

I personally love this book because I can identify with the characters, who are both flawed and genuine. All too often I’ve started reading a romance only to discover that both characters are gorgeous, billionaires, and have IQs over 180. I find such perfection uninteresting.

The two leads in To Have And To Hold, Sebastian and Rachel, are both train wrecks, although it is initially easier to see Rachel’s problems as she is currently a convict who is being released from prison. Sebastian’s behavior steps over the line. Way over the line. And the tension in most of the book will give you white knuckles. I have never forgotten these characters and their journey toward love was all the more rewarding for how hard-won it was.

The Proposition

By Judith Ivory,

Book cover of The Proposition

Why this book?

Wow, this book! Although it is a Pygmalion tale, that’s where any similarity ends to the original. London rat catcher Mick Tremore is truly from “the other side of the tracks” from heroine/linguist Lady Edwina Bolash. The differences between these two—cultural, social, sexual—make for oodles of fun right from the moment they crash into each other in a tea shop. 

It’s actually difficult to choose a favorite from Judith Ivory’s books as every single one of them is a unique work of historical romance art. Her writing is so clever and intelligent that you will learn while you’re being entertained. And her skill with character development is awe-inspiring. 


By Sherry Thomas,

Book cover of Delicious

Why this book?

My third book is Sherry Thomas’s Delicious, which features a female chef who ends up being the lover of two brothers who can’t stand each other. Once again, it is difficult to choose a favorite among Thomas’s books, but Delicious has such a fascinating series of side stories to go along with the main romance. Verity Durant, the heroine, is truly a strong female character and has paid a considerable societal price for her strength. It’s also nice to have protagonists who are in their thirties. There is just a touch of magical realism in the book when it comes to the meals that Verity cooks and their impact on Stuart, the hero. This book will give you all the feels!

Dancing with Clara

By Mary Balogh,

Book cover of Dancing with Clara

Why this book?

Mary Balogh is truly the grand dame of modern historical romance. Not only is she a reader favorite, but she has done her share of pushing the envelope when it comes to writing new and unusual romances. Dancing With Clara tackles a couple of taboos in romance—addiction and infidelity. The hero in the story is riddled with faults, and you will rip out your hair as you watch him undermine himself—and his marriage to Clara—over and over again. 

I’ve read criticisms of Clara—that she is a doormat—but I think Ms. Balogh accurately represented a Regency woman when she wrote Clara’s character. Especially a woman who was confined to a wheelchair and without even the meager options wealthy women had during the era. Don’t worry! There’s a happily ever after, but Clara and Freddie will bleed on the pages before they get it.

The Only Gold

By Tamara Allen, Cory Clubb (illustrator),

Book cover of The Only Gold

Why this book?

I’ve read this m/m romance multiple times for many reasons. First, it takes place in NYC. Second, both characters are working men (no dukes or millionaires!!) and Third, it is a hot, hot, hot enemies to lovers romance that gives the reader a vibrant picture of both the banking business at the end of the nineteenth century, but also tons of fascinating details about daily life and work culture. 

My favorite part of this story is the development of the relationship between the two leads. Both Jonah and Reid practically leap off the page. I love having an anal-retentive control freak paired with a charming, easy-going rogue.

5 book lists we think you will like!

Interested in romantic love, London, and World War 2?

5,887 authors have recommended their favorite books and what they love about them. Browse their picks for the best books about romantic love, London, and World War 2.

Romantic Love Explore 417 books about romantic love
London Explore 421 books about London
World War 2 Explore 976 books about World War 2

And, 3 books we think you will enjoy!

We think you will like Lord of Scoundrels, A Countess Below Stairs, and Spending if you like this list.