The best books of 2023

This list is part of the best books of 2023.

We've asked 1,624 authors and super readers for their 3 favorite reads of the year.

Shepherd is reader supported. When you buy books, we may earn an affiliate commission.

My favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of The Dead Mountaineer's Inn

Felice Picano Why did I love this book?

The Strugatsky brothers’ wrote Solaris—twice a film, though the Russian one is better. Also, Roadside Picnic, which spawned the haunting film, Stalker, territory Jeff Vandermeer has attempted to improve on.

So, I’d naturally be interested in reading DMI. A Russian detective on solo winter mountain vacation to ski and relax, stays at a place named after a famous climber who plunged to his death. At first the staff seems kind of ordinary and the guests who mostly arrive after him, seem a little off-kilter. But...not everything, in fact, almost no one and nothing is who (or what) it first appears to be.

I loved how the authors kept me totally, entertainingly, distracted with red herrings the size of Orcas, until the story spins delightfully out of our rigid narrator’s comprehension and control: for a totally unexpected and fully SF ending. 

By Boris Strugatsky, Arkady Strugatsky, Josh Billings (translator)

Why should I read it?

1 author picked The Dead Mountaineer's Inn as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

A hilarious spoof on the classic country-house murder mystery, from the Russian masters of sci-fi—never before translated
 
When Inspector Peter Glebsky arrives at the remote ski chalet on vacation, the last thing he intends to do is get involved in any police work. He’s there to ski, drink brandy, and loaf around in blissful solitude.
 
But he hadn’t counted on the other vacationers, an eccentric bunch including a famous hypnotist, a physicist with a penchant for gymnastic feats, a sulky teenager of indeterminate gender, and the mysterious Mr. and Mrs. Moses. And as the chalet fills up, strange things start…


My 2nd favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of Prefecture D

Felice Picano Why did I love this book?

I was completely immersed in Yokoyama’s huge and dense police novel Six Four and his detective mystery Seventeen, so why not try Prefecture D?

In this four-part book, brilliant detectives are not only minor characters, they’re not remotely the focus. Instead, we get bureaucrats in middle-high positions in the unnamed Police Department’s administration as protagonists. They are not only individuals in ambition, age, and character, they’re also each trying doggedly to solve problems others – including the detectives – not only don’t see, but interfere with constantly, making an even bigger mess of things.

I loved how the author drew me into the lives and work lives of four characters who I’d never suspected I could possibly be interested in, never mind be heroes and villains. And, how intimately, yet dryly humorous, and always surprising, their stories are. And then Yokoyama’s solutions kept me guessing each time.

By Hideo Yokoyama, Jonathan Lloyd-Davies (translator),

Why should I read it?

1 author picked Prefecture D as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

A collection of four novellas: each taking place in 1998, each set in the world of Six Four, and each centring around a mystery and the unfortunate officer tasked with solving it.

SEASON OF SHADOWS
"The force could lose face . . . I want you to fix this." Personnel's Futawatari receives a horrifying memo forcing him to investigate the behaviour of a legendary detective with unfinished business.
CRY OF THE EARTH
"It's too easy to kill a man with a rumour." Shinto of Internal Affairs receives an anonymous tipoff alleging a Station Chief is visiting the red-light district -…


My 3rd favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of The Haunting of L.

Felice Picano Why did I love this book?

This is an unexpected gift from a writer with solid literary credentials for his novels The Museum Guard, and The Birdwatcher.

It’s a young man’s romance that understands and presents love passionately, completely ill-advisedly, yet in the end, successfully. When our hero travels to western Canada he falls for a beauty with a creepy photographer husband hanging about.

She is a professional psychic and communicator with the dead who presents her discoveries to a mostly indifferent public. Meanwhile, her cynical, unloving husband finds and photographs scenes of shocking vehicle accident carnage for a mysterious tycoon in England with surprisingly good luck. Or is it?

I enjoyed this well told yet twisted story first for the characters who were totally one of a kind—even the walk-ons—and for how I never guessed how any of them could possibly succeed in getting what they really want. And then when they do get what they want, exactly what it will cost?    

By Howard Norman,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked The Haunting of L. as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

The final book in Howard Norman's Canadian Trilogy: a novel about spirit-photographs, adultery, and greed

It is 1927. Young Peter Duvett has accepted a job as an assistant to the elusive portraitist, Vienna Linn, in the remote town of Churchill, Manitoba. Peter's life is about to change in ways he scarcely could have imagined. Across Canada, Linn has been arranging and photographing gruesome accidents for the private collection, in London, of a Mr. Radin Heur-theirs is a macabre duet of art and violence.

After a strenuous journey, Peter arrives in Churchill on the very night of his employer's wedding only…


Plus, check out my book…

Six Strange Stories and an Essay on H.P. Lovecraft

By Felice Picano,

Book cover of Six Strange Stories and an Essay on H.P. Lovecraft

What is my book about?

Six stories in the slow-burn-to-a-chilling-finale tradition of tales by M.R. James, Robert Aickmann, and Walter De La Mare, but set in the contemporary world of Television series writers, high-end speculative real estate, and cutthroat corporate politics. The final, autobiographical and critical essay, "H.P. Lovecraft and Time", ‘’neatly and fondly summarizes the author’s thoughts on Lovecraft” wrote one reviewer, “while giving an indirect nod to the underlying theme for the anthology stories: how each of the characters begins to comprehend their own doom, and their inability to change it.”