Author Mystery lover Retired attorney Anglophile
The best books of 2023

This list is part of the best books of 2023.

We've asked 1,627 authors and super readers for their 3 favorite reads of the year.

Shepherd is reader supported. When you buy books, we may earn an affiliate commission.

My favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of Dead by Dawn

Judith Mathison Why did I love this book?

Maine Game Warden Investigator Mike Bowditch’s truck is sabotaged and plunges into the icy, swift moving Androscoggin River.

His beloved wolf-hybrid mix, Shadow, is inside a specially constructed kennel which Bowditch must breach to release him. For the next 24 hours, the game warden is chased by people he’s previously arrested now seeking vengeance. Shadow appears several times to warn him of his enemies’ moves.

The writing is tight, the story suspenseful and reminiscent of Lee Child’s 61 Hours, where Jack Reacher is also trapped by a blizzard and battles to save a special woman and others in South Dakota from a powerful assassin. Both men are resolute in seeking justice, bravely fighting the bad guys and the elements to do so.

Great characters, great storytelling. Doiron paints a Maine winter perfectly (my birthplace) and as the clock ticks down, the story never lags!

By Paul Doiron,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked Dead by Dawn as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.


My 2nd favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of Before Evil

Judith Mathison Why did I love this book?

Alex Kava has written a prequel to her Maggie O’Dell series 18 years after the first entry in the series, and 11 books later!

I was struck by the clever concept of going back to explain more about O’Dell, her serial killer arch-nemesis, Albert Stuckey, and the horrific cat-and-mouse games to which this monster subjected her. The author very deftly dives into these two fascinating characters, both with their human foibles.

Maggie O’Dell, FBI Special Agent and serial killer profiler, first appeared in A Perfect Evil. Stuckey is not the main killer in this book and only mentioned along with some of the damage he caused O’Dell, physically and mentally, by his torture and killing of two victims in front of her.

Her second book, Split Second, paints more of the Stuckey saga and his eventual escape from prison, but not until the prequel do we really understand how O’Dell was able to continue in her job, and manage to find a measure of peace and happiness. Kava’s character portraits are some of the best in the suspense genre, well worth checking out.

By Alex Kava,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked Before Evil as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

'O'Dell could be Reacher's long-lost twin' LEE CHILD

Special Agent Maggie O'Dell doesn't need to set foot at a crime scene to catch a serial killer. From her small Quantico office, she's profiled criminals using just Polaroids and faxed copies of evidence from homicide detectives across the country.

Then comes Albert Stucky . . . and nothing will ever be the same.

Stucky is a sadistic madman who places pieces of his victims in takeout containers and leaves them for innocent bystanders to find. He enjoys his twisted games as much as he enjoys the kill. And when Maggie is…


My 3rd favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of A Killing of Innocents

Judith Mathison Why did I love this book?

Deborah Crombie, a Texan, has authored this successful British series featuring two Scotland Yard detectives, Det. Sup. Duncan Kincaid and his wife Det. Insp. Gemma James. A Killing of Innocents is the 14th entry and it does not disappoint.

First, because Crombie knows the Brits well and writes like a native. Second, Crombie combines clever plots with a realistic portrayal of the couple and their balancing act of demanding police work while also maintaining a blended family with three children. 

The story concerns a stabbing victim Duncan notices in a pub. He is called to investigate the homicide, and so is Gemma, now employed at a different branch, but sent as part of a task force on the increase in knife crimes in London. Their parallel investigations twist and turn as another killing occurs, upping the ante to solve the murders.

Crombie highlights the different approaches Duncan and Gemma take to solve the crimes, along with assistants with their own fascinating subplots. Great read, very clever!

By Deborah Crombie,

Why should I read it?

2 authors picked A Killing of Innocents as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

New York Times bestseller Deborah Crombie returns with a new novel featuring Scotland Yard detectives Duncan Kincaid and Gemma James as they race to solve the shocking murder of a young woman before panic spreads across London.

On a rainy November evening, trainee doctor Sasha Johnson hurries through the evening crowd in London's historic Russell Square. Out of the darkness, someone jostles her as they brush past. A moment later, Sasha stumbles, then collapses. When Detective Superintendent Duncan Kincaid and his sergeant, Doug Cullen, are called to the scene, they discover that she's been stabbed. 

Kincaid immediately calls in his…


Plus, check out my book…

Dead Lawyers

By Judith Mathison,

Book cover of Dead Lawyers

What is my book about?

Cheater’s Lake, Washington, is rocketed into national news when local lawyers start dropping like flies. Bodies turn up in unlikely settings, while others connected to the legal biz mysteriously disappear. Could there be a serial killer at work, one who specializes in offing lawyers?

Detective Mark Walsh heads up the investigations, Newly transferred from Phoenix, he must weather small-town politics and decades-old secrets in his quest for the truth. Can Walsh get to the bottom of the pile of dead lawyers and find the killer or killers? Welcome to Cheater’s Lake!