Author Reader Library advocate Lover of mysteries Wisconsinite
The best books of 2023

This list is part of the best books of 2023.

We've asked 1,633 authors and super readers for their 3 favorite reads of the year.

Shepherd is reader supported. When you buy books, we may earn an affiliate commission.

My favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of Now Is Not the Time to Panic

Cayce Osborne Why did I love this book?

I am always astonished by the way Kevin Wilson brings out the unique humanity in his characters. None of his books rely on plot twists yet they are always surprising.

Now Is Not the Time to Panic is about creativity and art, friendship and growth, love and secrets. Two friends make an artsy poster. That poster captures the imagination of an entire town. And even as adults, they are still dealing with the fallout. It sounds simple, but this story is so much more. Wilson writes complex weirdos in a way that makes us realize that we’re all weirdos in our own (weird) little ways.

By Kevin Wilson,

Why should I read it?

2 authors picked Now Is Not the Time to Panic as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

NATIONAL BESTSELLER

Named a Best Book of the Year by: Time * Kirkus Reviews * USA Today * Entertainment Weekly * Garden & Gun * Vox * Atlanta Journal-Constitution

A Most Anticipated Book of Fall from: Associated Press * Atlanta Journal-Constitution * BookPage * Book Riot * The Boston Globe * Entertainment Weekly * Esquire * Garden & Gun * LitHub * St. Louis Post-Dispatch * Sunset Magazine * Time * Town & Country * The Millions * USA Today * Vogue * Vulture * The Week

An exuberant, bighearted novel about two teenage misfits who spectacularly collide one fateful…


My 2nd favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of Still True

Cayce Osborne Why did I love this book?

I know the characters in Still True so intimately now that I would recognize them if I passed them on the street.

The magic of literary fiction is that authors can explore whatever part of the story they want without having to conform to genre expectations. It’s relationships that Ginsberg explores in this beautifully written novel. When you spend your life with another person, you get to know them intimately. But there are secrets within all of us, even those we know the best.

This is a novel about personal struggles, truth, secrets, and all the ways there are to love someone. 

By Maggie Ginsberg,

Why should I read it?

3 authors picked Still True as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

One summer evening, Lib Hanson is confronted by her painful past when Matt Marlow, the forty-year-old son she abandoned as an infant, shows up on her porch. Fiercely independent, Lib has never revealed her son's existence-or her previous marriage-to her husband, Jack. Married nearly three decades but living in separate houses (to the confusion but acceptance of their neighbors), they enjoy an ease and comfort together in small-town Anthem, Wisconsin. But Jack is a stickler for honesty, and Lib's long-dormant secret threatens to unravel their lives.

When ten-year-old Charlie Taylor arrives at Jack's workshop shortly thereafter, he's not the first…


My 3rd favorite read in 2023…

Book cover of The Wonder State

Cayce Osborne Why did I love this book?

I love books with creepy houses, complicated friendships, grown-ups returning to their hometowns, dual timelines, and mysterious books that characters must decode.

The Wonder State has all these things. And not just one creepy house, but many! From the outside it might seem like your standard wayward-teens-get-into-trouble story, but it is so much more. It’s magical. It’s heartfelt. It’s clever. It’s atmospheric.

The houses in this book are more than homes. They are works of art, they are portals to the past, they are hideouts, they are solace, and they are terrible dangers, all at once.

By Sara Flannery Murphy,

Why should I read it?

1 author picked The Wonder State as one of their favorite books, and they share why you should read it.

What is this book about?

From the author of Girl One comes a spellbinding adventure about a strange power lurking in the Arkansas Ozarks, and the group of friends obsessed with finding it.

Five friends arrive back in Eternal Springs, the small town they all fled after high-school graduation. Each of them is drawn home by a cryptic, scrawled two-word letter: You promised.

It has been fifteen years since that life-changing summer, and they're anxious to find out why Brandi called them back, especially when they vowed never to return.

But Brandi is missing. She'd been acting erratically for months, in and out of rehab,…


Plus, check out my book…

I Know What You Did

By Cayce Osborne,

Book cover of I Know What You Did

What is my book about?

Petal Woznewski is content with her introverted life in New York City, but her peace is shattered when her name appears on the dedication page of an anonymously written novel: “I know what you did, Petal Woznewski. And now everyone else will too.”

The novel’s plot is rooted in a secret she buried thirty years earlier, involving the tragic death of her friend, Megan. A secret that only one other person knows—their old friend, Jenny. Petal returns to her hometown of Madison, Wisconsin to find the author, but discovers more questions than answers. Sinister clues pile up, and Petal must confront her past and solve the mystery of who wrote the book—before her very real life ends as tragically as the novel.